Senator Mark Bishop – Economics Committee Inquiry into the performance of ASIC

From Senator Mark Bishop

From: “Liau, Marie (Sen M. Bishop)” <Marie.Liau@aph.gov.au>
Date: 13 May 2014 8:54:04 AM AEST
To: XXXXX
Subject: Economics Committee Inquiry into the performance of ASIC
Dear Mr XXXThank you for your email recently received in our office and it has now been forwarded to the Economics Committee for consideration.As you are no doubt aware, the committee are due to table their report into the performance of ASIC on 30th May, 2014.  A copy of the report and its recommendation will then be available at http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/Economics/ASIC

Kind regards

Marie

Marie Liau

Office of Senator Mark Bishop

Perth tel: (08) 9472 6177 | fax: (08) 9472 6200
Canberra tel: (02) 6277 3101 | fax: (02) 6277 3123
mobile: 0488 914 221 | email: marie.liau@aph.gov.au

—– Forwarded message from XXXX —–
Date: Tue, 6 May 2014 12:57:08 +0800
From: XXXXXX
Subject: Enquiry Posted by XXXX to the Senator Mark Bishop
Contact Form
To: info@senatormarkbishop.com.au

Dear Sir/Madam,

This is the information that was submitted:

First Name           : XXX
Last Name            : XXX
Email Address        : XXXX
Telephone Number     : XXXX
Message              : We must have a ROYAL COMMISSION immediately
into the fraudulent activities of the banks.
:
: We have been conned & deceived by the
COMMONWEALTH BANK AUSTRALIA (CBA) & their agents using FRAUDULENT Loan
Application documents, in both 2005 and 2007.
:
: Our Loan Application Documents have been the
target of ‘Document Tampering, forgery & fraud.’
: Income figures were grossly inflated & many
other details,including false vehicles & shares, were altered & added
AFTER we had signed a couple of pages of the LAF.
:
: This is a  systemic, criminally fraudulent
business practice used by the CBA (and many other banks & lenders),
: where they corruptly lend money using grossly
falsified Loan Application Documents  (that we had never seen),
: & conspiring with Mortgage Brokers (that we
have never met), & going through Finance Companies (that we didn’t
know about & have never dealt with), with the sole aim of the Bank
being able to take our family home.
: (Asset Lending).
:
: Then the bank tries to cover it all up,
refuses to supply copies of the Loan Application Documents,
: –  CBA employee Quote:  ” We can’t give you
copies as it would leave the bank open to prosecution.”
:
: After 3 years of trying, I have all the other
documentation, including the falsified Loan Application Documents.
: They were fraudulently falsified in our 2005
loan and even more seriously in our 2007 loan re-finance.
: Fortunately for us they were dumb enough to
send us the 1st set of grossly altered documents – by mistake!
:
: I have also discovered that the bank (or their
agent) even used FAKE Low doc declarations that they photoshopped/ cut
& pasted together to get around the normal loan policies!  I also have
copies of these.
:
: One of the most shocking things about this is
that the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) -who are supposed to
protect the public from illegal or unethical banking practices – has
disturbingly decided that : even though the bank may have known that
the documentation was false – THE BANK WAS ENTITLED TO RELY ON THAT
FALSE DOCUMENTATION!
:
: The FOS are blatantly biased in favour of the
Banks. They have ignored key documentary evidence & overlooked much of
the fraudulent information.
:  My wife and I even discussed the possibility
of 2 of the FOS investigating officials being bribed, such was our
level of disbelief at the way they were constantly trying to justify
the Bank’s actions!
: At one stage, they stated that the bank would
have known that the income details had been falsified as we were
receiving Family Assistance so therefore could not have been earning
the income stated on the loan application, and were suggesting that
the Bank should enter into a settlement conference and were waiting
for the Bank to respond.
: The next letter we had from the ombudsman was
the final decision – in favour of the bank!
:
: Even more sinister the ombudsman also put in a
clause stating that : if we accept the decision that we were to agree
not to take any further action against the bank!  This is how they try
to protect the Banks, they are certainly not protecting the public
against this fraud.
:
: We also recently received a copy of a letter
from FOS to the CBA- which was deliberately with-held from us, stating
that FOS’ Legal Counsel agreed that the CBA WAS GUILTY of
MALADMINISTRATION!
:
: We were actually advised by one of the FOS
Investigating Case Managers who realised that important matters in the
investigation were being covered up in favour of the bank, to go to
the State & Federal Police to make an official complaint against them
for fraud, which is what we have done.
:
: The Australian Federal Police and the CRIMINAL
INVESTIGATIONS BRANCH are now investigating both the CBA and the
brokers for Criminal Fraud.
: The CIB Detectives have issued warrants on the
CBA trying to get the ORIGINAL documents, but the CBA have responded
by stating that the original documents would have been destroyed.
:
: We are now at the stage where we arranged
meetings with our local MP  Karen Andrews, & took copies of the
documents to show her.  She agreed that fraud was evident & agreed
that we should make a formal complaint with the police.
: We also have the full support of Mr. White, of
the National Federation of Independent Business.
:
: This widespread fraud must be stopped.
: It is a crime against the Commonwealth, it is
a crime against all the People of Australia.
:
: The bank executives must be held accountable
for instigating this fraud & allowing the corruption to continue.
: Fraud is a criminal offence, therefore they
must be prosecuted to the full extent of the Law.
:
: We have written over 50 letters to the CBA CEO
Ian Narev and all of the other Directors, and we have sent Formal
Claims, by registered post, to all the CBA Board of Directors
individually, but they have not responded to us except to try & drag
us into a long & expensive legal battle by saying: “We will only
respond to you through a Lawyer.”
: Interestingly, they also haven’t denied or
rebutted our allegations of fraud,- because they know that we have the
documentation, in black & white, that proves this fraud.
: yours sincerely,
: XXXXXX
: XXXXXX

Message End.

Australian Securities and Investment Commission – Senate Hearing Committee

Australian Parliament:   Senate Hearing Committee into the performance of corporate regulator ASIC - Australian Securities and Investment Commission

Held at Australian Parliament House over 3 days - Links to Schedule

(Transcripts will be added as they become available)

Public Hearings

SENATE ECONOMICS REFERENCES COMMITTEE DAY 1

The performance of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission

PUBLIC HEARING Wednesday 19 February 2014  Program Day 1

Corinthian Room, Sydney Masonic Conference & Function Centre (SMC), 66 Goulburn St Sydney

Time

Witness

9.00 am

Australian Securities and Investments Commission
(Submission 45,  45_supp 45_supp245_supp2_correction45_supp3 )

Mr Greg Medcraft, Chairman
Mr Peter Kell, Deputy Chairman
Mr John Price, Commissioner

Mr Greg Tanzer, Commissioner
Ms Cathie Armour, Commissioner
Mr Greg Kirk, Senior Executive Leader, Strategy Group
Mr Warren Day, Senior Executive Leader Stakeholder Services and Regional Commissioner for Victoria
Mr Chris Savundra, Senior Executive Leader, Markets Enforcement

10.30 am

Break

10.45 am

Continued:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission

Mr Greg Medcraft, Chairman

12.00 pm

Institute of Chartered Accountants Australia (Submission 203) Mr Lee White FCA, Chief Executive Officer

CPA Australia (Submission 209)
Mr Alex Malley FCPA, Chief Executive Officer Mr Paul Drum, Head of Policy

1.00 pm

Lunch

1.45 pm

Academic panel:

Professor Dimity Kingsford Smith (Submission 153)
Professor Justin O’Brien and Dr George Gilligan (Submission 121) Dr Suzanne Le Mire and A/Prof David Brown (Submission 152)

3.15 pm

Community and Public Sector Union (Submission 125) Mr Alistair Waters, Deputy National President
Mr David Mawson, CPSU ASIC Workplace Delegate

3.55 pm

Break

4.05 pm

Financial Planning Association of Australia (Submission 234) Mr Mark Rantall, Chief Executive Officer
Mr Dante De Gori, General Manager Policy and Conduct
Mr John Bacon, General Manager, Professional Standards

Association of Financial Advisers (Submission 117) Mr Brad Fox, Chief Executive Officer
Mr Marc Bineham, Vice President

5.00 pm

Adjournment

Committee Chair: Senator Mark Bishop
PO Box 6100, Parliament House Canberra ACT 2600 Tel: +61 2 6277 3540 Fax: +61 2 6277 5719

Email: economics.sen@aph.gov.au Internet: www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/Economics

SENATE ECONOMICS REFERENCES COMMITTEE DAY 2

The performance of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission

PUBLIC HEARING Thursday 20 February 2014 Program Day 2

Corinthian Room, Sydney Masonic Conference & Function Centre (SMC), 66 Goulburn St Sydney

Time

Witness  

9.00 am

Law Council of Australia (Submission 150)
Mr John Keeves, Chairman, Business Law Section
Mr Bruce Dyer, Member of the Corporations Committee, Business Law Section

10.00 am

Commonwealth Ombudsman (Submission 188)
Mr Colin Neave, Ombudsman

11.00 am

Break

11.15 am

Financial Ombudsman Service (Submission 193)
Mr Shane Tregillis, Chief Ombudsman
Mr Philip Field, Lead Ombudsman, Banking and Finance

Credit Ombudsman Service

Mr Raj Venga, Chief Executive Officer and Ombudsman Mr Scott Goodison, Head of Dispute Resolution
Ms Allison Dam, Head of Policy and Compliance

12.15 pm

Lunch

1.00 pm

Australian Institute of Superannuation Trustees (Submission 136)
Mr David Haynes, Executive Manager, Policy and Research
Ms Karen Volpato, Senior Policy Adviser

Industry Super Australia (Submission 201)
Ms Robbie Campo

2.00 pm

Consumer Action Law Centre (Submission 120_att,  120)
Mr Gerard Brody, Chief Executive Officer (possibly via teleconference)

Consumer Credit Legal Centre (NSW) Inc (Submission 194)
Ms Karen Cox, Coordinator

3.00 pm

Break

3.15 pm

Banking and Finance Consumers Support Association (Inc) (Submission 156_supp1,  156)
Ms Denise Brailey

4.15 pm

Adjournment

4.30 pm

Public hearing for the inquiry: Ticket scalping in Australia (until 5.30pm)

THE SENATE

SENATE ECONOMICS REFERENCES COMMITTEE

The performance of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission

PUBLIC HEARING Friday 21 February 2014 Day 3 Program Day 3

Committee Room 2S1, Parliament House Canberra

Time

Witness

10.00 am

Mr Niall Coburn (Submission 282)

10.45 am

Break

11.00 am

Professor Robert Baxt AO (Submission 189)

12.00 pm

Department of the Treasury

Ms Dianne Brown, Acting General Manager, Corporations and Capital Markets Division
Mr Bede Fraser, Manager, Intermediaries and Regulatory Powers Unit, Retail Investor Division

1.00 pm

Adjournment

1.45 pm

Public hearing for the inquiry: Tax Laws Amendment (Research and Development) Bill 2013 (until 4pm)